Thursday, 26 June 2014
Pitbull ruins everything: Why TikTok is better than Timber
Friday, 8 November 2013
Nudity, femininity and the animal kingdom: Would Robin Thicke objectify a woman?
However, what is potentially more problematic than the severe imbalance in clothing distribution is the whole narrative of domestication, and narrative of women as animals. He sings:
Ok now he was close, tried to domesticate you
but you're an animal, baby it's in your nature
You don't need no papersThat man is not your maker
Let me be the one you back that ass to
[...]
Yeah, I had a bitch, but she ain't bad as you
So hit me up when you pass through
I'll give you something big enough to tear your ass in two
[...]
Nothing like your last guy, he too square for you
He don't smack that ass and pull your hair like that
There has been some debate over whether this video truly objectifies women, as the creators have argued that they are mocking explicit pop videos by including references to all that is taboo, including nudity, drug use and bestiality. Furthermore, one of the topless women has stated that she did not feel objectified, and she wanted to undermine the nudity taboo. All very admirable. However, rather like Ms Cyrus, the model in question has missed the point about objectification: it does not require the object's consent. While the fact that she is able to speak publicly about her performance and provide a reading of her own nudity which counters the general assumption that she is being objectified does go some way towards recontextualizing the video, she is nevertheless naked and surrounded by clothed men singing about her as an object of desire.
However, this whole thing could be read as not so much an attempt to shamelessly objectify women with merry abandon, as a poor, confused man's cry for help. This would be summed up in the image of a naked ass with a stop sign on it towards the end of the video:
Friday, 1 November 2013
The (anti?)feminist discourse of Miley Cyrus's bare bottom
1) In the context of common practice in Pop music, are Ms Cyrus's performances that unusual?
2) When is nudity objectification and when is it art?
3) Does the objectification of Ms C's body spell the death of feminism?
Before I answer these questions, here is a brief summary of my impressions of the two offending articles, for those unwilling to tarnish their retinas and/or souls by watching the originals:
Exhibit A: The Twerking Incident
This is MC's MTV VMA Performance: the act opens with her flouncing out of the innards of a giant teddy bear, wearing a leotard with some sort of demented mouse on the front, her tongue hanging out like she's caught some sort of rare sheep disease; as though she were innocently on her way to a pre-teen modern
dance class when she suddenly became the first victim of a zombie apocalypse. She proceeds with a dance routine that would not have been entirely alien to the aforementioned pre-teen modern dance class, with the exception of the occasional crotch thrust, and bending over and shaking her bum, a move apparently called 'twerking'. The song in the background pronounces that 'It's our party, we'll do what we want'.
Following this, she rips off her leotard to reveal something resembling a beige 1950s bikini,
proceeds to mime pleasuring herself with a foam finger, and repeats the 'twerking' move, this time rubbing her bum against a somewhat lecherous-looking male singer who is wearing a thick striped black and white suit that makes him look like a used-car salesman. The chorus to the song for this scene is 'You're such a good girl. I know you want it.' So far, so tasteless, but hardly unusual for the world of pop.
Exhibit B: The Nudity Incident
This, she claims, was inspired by Sinead O'Connor's 1990 video for 'Nothing Compares 2U'.While O'Connor's video consists mainly of close-ups of the singer's face with some tears towards the end, Cyrus's goes on to show the singer writhing in her underwear in a partially demolished building. Then she is seen swinging around on a wrecking ball wearing nothing but her boots.
At one point, she also licks a hammer. The song itself is about the dissolution of a relationship, in which Cyrus describes herself as a well-intentioned 'wrecking ball', who only wanted to break down the nameless addressee's defenses. And yet, apparently, it is her who is wrecked. Whatever.
1) In the context of common practice in Pop music, are Ms Cyrus's performances that unusual?
No, they are not. So why are Miley Cyrus's performances more shocking than other semi-naked and sexualized women's pop videos?
To a large extent, what makes MC's 'sexy dancing' disturbing is the fact that she still effectively looks like a child. At the age of 20, she could still easily pass for about fourteen, and so her objectification is more disturbing than that of an older-looking woman, as her claims to be making her own decisions appear less credible. To some extent, this may be her motivation for engaging in shock tactics: having become famous as a child, to a child-audience, she wants to prove that she has grown up by presenting herself as seductive as well as capable of great emotion.
Unfortunately, the effect is cringe-inducing, rather than artistically effective. The extreme stylization of her video makes her emotion appear fake, while the protrusion of her apparently still-budding breasts through a ribbed vest evokes the horror of the image of an objectified child. By comparison, the scenes where she is wearing nothing and swinging around on the wrecking ball are a relief, because at least nothing controversial is actually visible- it reminds me of naked calendars you can buy, made by various amateur sports clubs to raise money, where sporting equipment hides the subject's intimate areas: not very shocking, and a bit twee.
To return to the VMA performance, Cyrus appears to be deliberately deconstructing her previous public persona: the demented mouse leotard is a corruption of Mickey Mouse who represents wholesome childhood, while all the sad-faced dancing teddy-bears and suchlike follow a similar theme. She keeps pointing to her sexuality, literally, by pointing to her vagina. But while I find comedians, such as Sarah Millican, making jokes about vaginas both funny and pleasantly challenging to social convention, Miley's performance reminded me more of a little girl I knew, aged two: during nappy changes, she would point at her bum, and say 'bum!' with an extremely smug look on her face, showing her pride in discovering the location of her bum, and knowing the word by which to identify it. Similarly, Miley seems to have discovered her vagina, but unfortunately has not yet learned the words to articulate her joy in this discovery.
2) When is nudity objectification and when is it art?
If the impressionists could get away with painting naked women in the nineteenth century, why can't Miley swing around naked on a wrecking ball to her heart's content?
3) Does the objectification of Ms C's body spell the death of feminism?
No - not more so than any other objectified woman in a pop video does. However, it does show that gender equality is still a long way off.
If one takes a lipstic feminist position, Miley Cyrus' current public persona could represent a re-appropriation of her body and femininity through the open enactment of her sexuality and the flaunting of her nudity. However, due to the creme cracker - tree frog hypothesis detailed above, this reading seems far-fetched. It is exceedingly likely that Ms Cyrus' performances are doing nothing but perpetuate the sinister objectification of women in popular music culture, often to a vulnerable audience who were introduced to her in her insipid but safe incarnation as Hannah Montana. Is the world likely to end as a result? No. With any luck, one day she will put her pants back on and produce some music that doesn't perpetuate all that is bad in the world, both aurally and ideologically. I'm not holding my breath, though.
Friday, 25 January 2013
Death and the Father: ‘Chop Suey’
Chop Suey
God be in my eyes and in my looking
God be in my mouth and in my speaking
God be in my heart and in my thinking
God be at my end and at my departing
self-righteous suicide
Friday, 30 November 2012
Self and Double in Audioslave and Charalambides
the double was originally an insurance against the destruction of the ego, an ‘energetic denial of the power of death’, as [Otto] Rank says; and probably the ‘immortal’ soul was the first ‘double’ of the body. […] Such ideas, however, have sprung from the soil of unbounded self-love, from the primary narcissism which dominates the mind of the child and of primitive man. But when this stage has been surmounted, the ‘double’ reverses its aspect. From having been an assurance of immortality, it becomes the uncanny harbinger of death. (Freud, The Uncanny, in The Norton Anthology of Theory and Criticism, p. 940)
The double as discussed by Freud and Otto Rank is a concept that often engages artists, from the most diverse backgrounds. I was struck by the uncanny appearance of the double in Audioslave’s ‘Exploder’ and Kyriakos Charalambides’ ‘(Hi)Story with a horse in it’. In both texts, the artist encounters his double, and ultimately destroys him.
Audioslave’s ‘Exploder’ deals with themes of mental illness: the first stanza describes a man who has been committed to a mental institution, the second a girl who copies her father and commits suicide and a boy who hears voices and kills his mother. Each stanza is followed by the chorus, which almost ritualistically repeats that ‘If you’re free you’ll never see the walls’. This fits in with the theme of questioning control over one’s actions: the girl in the second stanza commits suicide despite having expressed the intention not to (‘she said she’d never do the same, then did just what he’d done’), while the boy who kills his mother is presumably acting on the instructions of the mysterious voices in his head (‘no one knows what they said, now his mother’s dead’). In the third stanza, the speaker looks upon himself, quite literally: he encounters his double:
I saw a man who had a face that looked a lot like me
I saw him in the mirror and I fought him in the streets
Then when he turned away I shot him in the head
Then I came to realize I had killed myself
In this instance, the speaker’s belated recognition of himself intensifies the uncanny sense of the encounter. In Charalambides’ poem, there is a similar delay in recognition, although this is because the speaker is initially unable to see his double. He is told by others that he can be seen riding his horse through the skies of Lefkosia, but it takes time for him to encounter himself:
Όμως μια μέρα σαν κι αυτή – παράξενο! – είδα
τούτο που λέγανε. Και μη νομίσεις
πως σου μιλώ για πήγασους και τα τοιαύτα.
Άλογο ήτανε, γερό και στιβαρό
χωρίς φτερά και μ’ ένα χαλινάρι
χοντρό σαν το χαλάζι – εγώ π’ ουδέποτε
σ’ άλογο ανέβηκα, και να καλπάζω.
But a day like that – strange! – I saw
what they were talking about. And don’t think
that I’m telling you about pegassi and suchlike.
A horse it was, strong and solid
without wings and with reigns
as thick as hail – and I who never
on a horse had ridden, up there and galloping.
In this case, the sense of the uncanny is evoked both by the existence of the double, and by his seeming disdain of the laws of Physics. He is riding through the sky on a real, solid, heavy horse. Like in ‘Exploder’, the speaker must assert himself over his double through an act of violence. He pierces the sack of air holding the horseman aloft, and drags him to the ground, finally killing him:
Όμως τον πρόλαβα μπροστά στο βασιλιά
και μια και δυο τον ξετελειώνω – να μη λένε
ότι με βλέπουνε καβάλα στ’ άλογό μου
επάνω από τον ουρανό της Λευκωσίας.
But I caught up with him before the king
and chop chop, I finish him off – so they don’t say
that they see me astride my horse
up in the sky of Leukosia.
The main difference between these two murders of the double is that in ‘Exploder’ the speaker only discovers that he has killed his double after the event, where as in ‘horse’ the speaker deliberately murders his double to protect the integrity of the identity of the self. However, the violent outcome in these two instances may point towards the desire of the artist to control the image of the self. While ‘Exploder’ creates an uncanny setting through the questioning of the accuracy of perception entailed in the delayed recognition of the double, the same degree of uncanny is evoked in Charalambides’ poem through the dreamlike structure of the narrative. The sequence of events is presented as causal, but this association is elusive to the wakeful mind.
In conclusion, it could be argued that the figure of the double poses a particular threat to the artist, and must be eradicated at all costs. Also, American rock music and Cypriot-Greek intellectual poetry have things in common.
Thursday, 29 November 2012
So what's this all about, then?
I was recently writing a PhD thesis, and I had all these ideas that were tangentially related but didn't quite fit in with the central theme. Like the Freudian overtones of many rock songs. Also, I just like to overanalyse things. So I decided to put all this stuff here. Feel free to set me straight if you think I am misreading something...
